Here’s my A List line up for the best EYE products.
(Oh, and to check out my previous posts on best hair, body, face, and lip products check out the Archives to the bottom right).
It was painful narrowing it down.
1. MAC Eye Kohl $16
Unlike some black ones, the color won’t wuss out to gray after hours of wear.
2. Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Liner $23
All 13 silky colors, including best seller Black Ink, cling to lids on the first try and won’t move,
3. MAC Liquid Liner $17
Get smoldering eyes from this little compact. The creamy eyeliner can be applied wet for a precise line or dry for a smudged effect.
4. Maybelline Lash Stiletto $7
(All around liquid liner)
This is my favorite drug store liner. It goes on so easily, perfect for those that aren’t pros at applying liquid liner. I use it a lot for my daytime cat eye. Easiest application ever and it never fades.
5. Sue Devitt $22
With its velvety texture, it glides on smoothly without tugging or pulling, and the foam point on the opposite end can be used to smudge a line for a smoky, sexy look.
6. Revlon Color Stay $6
(All around pencil liner)
Ease of application, fade proof and it glides on without pulling your lids.
1. Chanel Illusion d’Ombre in Illusoire $36
(Shade for Olive Skin)
Bathes lids in a purple so multidimensional, it’s hard to believe you’re wearing just one color.
2. Maybelline New York Color Tattoo $7
It’s got the ease of a cream and the longevity of a powder. The nine vibrant colors are split between bolds and neutrals, like top seller Bad to the Bronze.
3. Josie Maran Beautiful Eyes $36
These nontoxic shadows are loaded with argan oil and flower extracts (even the compact is biodegradable. The palettes contain universal colors that women of any age can wear. Nice plus.
4. MAC in Amber Lights $13
(Shade for Dark skin)
Easy to layer, the pearlescent bronze warms the skin as much as the eyes.
5. L’Oréal HIP $8
Fun, vibrant, exciting—just a few of the words makeup experts use to describe these shadows that are pretty impressive for the steal. With 35 long-wear shades in five finishes, there are infinite possibilities to mix and match.
6. Nars in Mekong $24
(Shade for Dark skin)
Like freshly ground gourmet coffee, this extra-shimmery chocolate shadow wakes up sleepy eyes.
7. Tom Ford in Cognac Sable $75
(Shade for Olive skin)
This dramatic quad has all you need for a shimmery, smoky look. I know it’s pricey but it’s a luxe brand with just as luxe shades.
8. Chanel in Taupe Grisé $25
(Shade for Fair skin)
Drapes lids in a nude-gray veil that’s never boring.
9. Nars Duos Eye Shadow $33
These featherweight powders can be blended together and applied with a wet brush to create a bold, gutsy look. The best part? The color you see in the package is exactly what you get. I love that.
10. Benefit in Busy Signal
(Shade for Med-Dark skin)
Apply with a fingertip to create a sheer wash of bronze that brightens eyes.
11. Lorac Starry-Eyed Baked Eye Shadow Trio in Superstar $24
Champagne, fawn and cocoa add definition and a really pretty shimmer. Great shade for those holiday parties.
12. CoverGirl Smoky ShadowBlast in Bronze Fire $9
(Shade for Med-Dark skin)
This iridescent duo produces a gorgeous sheen.
13. Bobbi Brown Shimmer Wash Eyeshadow in Black Plum $20
(Shade for Dark skin)
A metallic brown that isn’t too sparkly so you can go from day to night. The perfect transition color.
14. Stila Eye Shadow Pans in Kitten $18
I die over this color. Kitten is everything. It’s a glimmering champagne and it’s the perfect balance of light and dark for a unique pop. Great as a highlighter, as well as for the bottom lash line. (That’s my secret for bright eyes).
15. Estée Lauder Pure Color EyeShadow in Copper Penny $18
A metallic brown brightens eyes without being overly sparkly.
16. MAC Eye Shadow in Embark $15
A MAC shade fav. Trace it along the bottom lashes to make eyes appear bigger.
17. Nars Cream Eyeshadow in Corfu $21
This pearlescent beige cream is so sheer and blendable, it’s nearly impossible to overdo.
18. Revlon Eye Shadow $8
The pros absolutely love these shadows. It’s not frosty and comes in the perfect rang of shades. Takes the guesswork out of choosing complimentary shades.
19. NARS Cream Shadow $21
Unlike many other cream shadows, these don’t migrate to the crease of your lid after a few hours, plus the color stays true rather than fading or rubbing off.
20. MAC Eye Shadow $18
One of my biggest collections, the texture of these shadows is amazing. So many finishes, and so many colors. I need a catalogue of what I have when I go shopping for new ones. 140 colors available.
21. L’Oréal Studio Secrets Professional Crystal Shadow Duo $8
Available in subtle matte, shimmery or deeply pigmented shades, these silky, crease-resistant shadow duos are one of the best out there.
22. Stila Eye Shadow in Jezebel $18
(Med-Fair skin shadow)
23. Stila Eye Shadow in Golightly $18
(Shade for Dark skin)
24. MAC Paints $17
These blend amazingly and are dry yet have a really nice reflective finish.
25. Chanel Ombre D’eau Fluid Iridescent Eye Shadow $32
Liquid shimmer packaged in frosted glass, this new line of shadows delivers a smooth, luminous finish. Once it dries you can layer on more for maximum-impact glimmering color.
1. L’Oréal Voluminous Waterproof $8
This cult fav gives length and fullness and stays put through anything worthy of a tear jerker. Ugly cries too.
2. L’Oréal Voluminous Original $6
This panthenol-enriched product thickens so well that for falsie – events you can go ahead and skip them.
3. Dior Diorshow $25
The jumbo wand inflates even the puniest fringe. Layer as much as you like—this stuff won’t clump.
4. Lancôme Hypnôse Waterproof $26
Waterproof mascaras can be a touch too stiff. But with this pliable formula, “I can build volume, and it layers really well.
5. Maybelline Great Lash Mascara $5
So 90’s. The classic continues to impress with its buildable, natural formula in seven conditioning shades.
6. Lancôme Definicils High Definition Mascara $25
Most of the mascaras that promise not to run become stiff within seconds, making it difficult to build up a full, vampy fringe. But this supple lash-plumper takes more time to set,
7. Clinique High Lengths Mascara $14
This gently arched, flexible wand yields elegant results: Lush, fully coated lashes in just a few swipes. And although the rich formula is loaded with potent conditioners and proven thickeners, it still goes on silky and clump-free.
8. Cover Girl Lash Blast Fusion Mascara $9
With a spiky yet flexible brush this mascara lengthens and volumizes with just a few swipes. So much so that people have asked us if we’re wearing false lashes—no joke.
9. Tarte Bottoms Up Lower Lash Mascara $16
For those moments that call for extra drama, this mascara does the trick. Its tiny bristles grab and separate hard-to-reach lower lash hairs for a wide-eyed Twiggy look.
10. Lancome L’Extreme’ Instant Extensions Lengthening Mascara $25
This brush applies, defines, and separates amazingly.
11. Maybelline Lash Discovery Waterproof Mascara $7
Find a lot of clumping with your waterproof mascara? This formula and brush are designed to ferret out smaller lashes and keep them separated and lush.
12. Chanel Inimitable $30
Just one stroke is all it takes for lengthening, separating and volumizing. It really makes the lashes stand out.
13. L’Oreal Voluminous Volume Building Mascara $8
Great price for a huge impact.
14. Max Factor Volume Couture $9
his mascara’s ingenious, comblike brush spreads the thickening formula evenly onto each lash. The result? Naturally lush, fluttery lashes that aren’t overloaded with mascara.
15. Benefit They’re Real Mascara $23
One of my go-to’s, the specially designed brush features staggered bristles that grab close to the root, boosting length and volume beyond belief. The custom-domed tip uses precision bristles to lift, define, and curl even your tiniest lashes. With a glossy, jet-black, long-wearing formula, you’ll flaunt luxurious, silky lashes that won’t smudge, clump, or dry out.
16. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara $23
Inspired by the curves of a woman’s body, the hourglass-shaped brush was designed with extra stiff bristles to maximize the performance of this carbon black, collagen-fueled formula. One coat and lashes are full and defined. Two coats and lashes are even more luscious, curled, and dramatic. Three coats help you achieve the most intense, black, multidimensional lashes possible. I can’t stress how amazing this stuff is. I swear by it.
17. Yves Saint Laurent Volume Effet Faux Clis Baby Doll $30
Baby Doll creates a full open-eye effect by lifting and separating lashes. The patented formula creates long-lasting volume and intense color that is evenly dispersed with no flakes, clumps, or smudges for up to 24 hours.
1. Anastasia Brow Wiz $21
The not-too-creamy,not-too-dry texture provides “a feathery look that best mimics natural brows and comes in 6 hues.
2. Kevyn Aucoin The Precision Brow Pencil $24
The ideal shade—not too yellow, not too dark. Plus it has a self sharpening tip.
3. Shiseido Eyebrow and Eyeliner Compact $30
This kit offers the best non smudge colors. Use the lighter shade during the day for a natural look and the darker shade at night to make brows more dramatic.
4. Anastasia Beverly Hills $22
Anastasia Soare trained as an architect and, fittingly, her expert line of products serve as building blocks for well-constructed brows. The color selection is extremely vast and can create the most perfectly defined brows.
5. Benefit Brow Zings $30
The kit includes a soft, pigmented wax that defines and shapes brows and a color complementing setting powder to keep them looking wow, plus discreet tweezers for pesky stray hairs, a hard angle brush, and a blending brush.
6. Smashbox Brow Tech To Go $23
A double-ended applicator that has an angled long-wearing waterproof pencil on one side and a soft-hold gel with a brow brush applicator on the other. The double-ended component includes an angled, long-wearing waterproof pencil for precise filling and defining and a soft-hold gel with a brow brush applicator to groom brows perfectly into place.
7. Benefit High Brow $22
I love this stuff. It’s great for brightening and lift. Get expressive brows in seconds with this brow lifting and enhancing pencil. With one quick stroke directly under the arch of your brow, this soft, oyster-pink pencil instantly adds lift and life to the entire eye area.
8. Sephora Collection Eyebrow Editor Complete Brow Kit $20
This compact kit includes everything you need for customizing your look, including two brow powders that can be combined to create your perfect filler shade. Apply these defining powders with the included angle brush and then follow up with the spoolie brush for specialized shaping. The kit also includes a tweezer for shaping and a setting wax to keep unruly brows in line. Everything you need.